
Welfare programs–Some basics
Four major means-tested programs (2011-13 figures)
Welfare program | background | No. current recipients (2011) | Avg. benefit / recipient / month | Annual outlays (2011) |
SSI supplemental security income | 1973 version replaced earlier versions, begun in 1930s | 8.3 (million) | $554 in ’12 | $46(billion) |
TANF temporary assistance to needy families | replaced AFDC in 1996; ADC in 1935 | $350 in | $13 billion (in 2011 budget) | |
EITC: earned income tax credit for working poor | created in 1975 | 28 million | $241 ($2,905/yr) | $59 billion in 2011 |
GA: general assistance | for needy not fitting other categories(childless couples, individuals) | 1.4 (almost defunct now) | $190 ($2,280/yr) | $3 billion |
Totals | 38.6 million | $120 billion |
SSI: Supplemental security income
- Serves adults and children
- Provides cash for food, clothing, shelter
- Aged, blind, disabled–‘the worthy’
- SSI varies by state (minimum federal baseline amounts are supplemented by many states)
- This is the ‘deserving’ population . . . 1973 program replaced 2 separate programs with standardized eligibility tests and administration
TANF: temporary assistance for needy families
- Cash assistance, temporary, plus other in-kind services
- If you work: child care, child support enforced, medical coverage provided, if there is money available
- 5 year lifetime limit; 2 years consecutive, then you need a job (varies by state)
- states can exempt up to 20% of the population from the time limits
- focus here on temporary–welfare as a transitory state
- officially: provide assistance to needy families so children may be cared for in home or homes of relatives;
- end dependency of needy parents on govt. benefits by promoting job prep., work and marriage
- prevent/reduce incidence of out-of-wedlock pregnancies
- encourage formation and maintenance of two-parent families
- reducing rolls: TANF isn’t an adequate safety net
- Benefits haven’tkept up with inflation
EITC: Earned income tax credit
- Payment to working poor-subsidy of 40% on low wages-it’s applied to their tax liability-so they only get money back if the credit exceeds the liability (this graphshould help understand)
- Average credit for yr 2000 was about $1,500
- 19 million households received EITCs in 2000
- qualifications: money earned during year; qualifying child living in home; earned income less than $31,150 with more than one ‘qualifying’ child; those getting credit must have social security numbers; fraudulent claims will get you a ten year suspension from eligibility;
- Above $12,500, the credit begins to decrease (disappears into 21% base tax rate)
- encouraging people to work–here’s a question for you: is it a subsidy for workeres, or employers?
In-kind programs
These include food stamps, Medicaid, housing assistance, and nutrition programs like the federally subsidized programs we’ve talked about in the hunger project). Below are some data on these, it’s hard data to pull together, so pay attention as much to proportions as anything, and keep in mind those pie charts–which don’t change too much–that show discretionary budget categories.
program | no. recipients | avg. benefit / recipient / month | total annual cost (’09) |
45 million) in ’11 | $133 | $56 billion | |
62 million in ’11 | $251 billion | ||
housing assistance (HUD) | 11 million | 159 | $21 billion |
31 million in ’10 | $26 | $10.8 billion | |
WIC (women, infants and children) | 9.2 million | $6.7 billion | |
totals | $345.5 billion |
source: U.S. Census Bureau, Office of Management and Budget
SNAP is a federal program we should all be pretty familiar with. Medicaid (called Oregon Health Plan here) is federally funded, but state-administered. As one of the brushes articles notes, there is a stigma associated with the use of Medicaid, and some physicians simply don’t accept Medicaid patients. Federal housing assistance is designed to reduce rent payments for people with low incomes. The in-kind programs often involve being put on waiting lists, and this can be one of the longer waits. There are public housing projects, public-assisted housing, and tenant-based assistance (tenant can choose his/her own place, provided the landlord will take the money–another ‘brushes’ experience). There are also federally-funded nutrition programs, which include WIC, for pregnant women and mothers of children under one year. There are food voucher programs, which we’ve discussed, school lunch programs, and commodity programs (where local food banks get much of their food, along with food drive contributions).
PRWORA (personal responsibility and work opportunity reconciliation act of 1996, i.e. welfare reform): Some provisions, key points:
- Drafted and passed by Republican-controlled House of Representatives; signed by President Clinton;
- Gave more power to states (‘devolution’); designed to keep more children in their own homes or with relatives (why?); focus on job preparation, work, and marriage; discouraged out of wedlock pregnancies (as opposed to, say, births?); encouraged formation of two-parent families
- The current $300 million marriage promotion is an effort to apply funding to what has been an unfunded part of the 1996 legislation;
- Block grants are federal funds administered by states; TANF is block grant-again, more devolution (further ‘federalizing’ AFDC);
- Time limits: 60 months on cash assistance (states may reduce this); states can exempt up to 20% of recipients, and can continue beyond limits with their own funds (few reportedly do, however–have you checked out state budgets lately?);
- Work requirements: after two years of cash assistance; states face financial penalties for not moving a certain percentage off of welfare–the key measure is reducing welfare rolls;
- Family cap: families already receiving assistance will not gain new benefits with additional children–the underlying assumption being . . . ?
Some basic issues/questions
Sources of money
- Public
- Private
- Non-profit (how raised?)
How administered (some of the more prominent services/agencies):
- Public agencies
- Department of Human Services (DHS) has three divisions:
- Social Security Administration (SSA, OASDI)
- HUD (Northeast Oregon Housing Authority, NEOHA)
- Criminal Justice
- Union County Courthouse/Circuit Court
- Union County Sheriff’s Dept.
- La Grande Police Dept.
- Oregon State Police(OSP)
- Union County Community Corrections(adult parole/probation, juvenile services)
- Union County Victims Assistance
- Non-profits
- Mental Health Organization (MHO, each Oregon County has at least one, Union’s is CHD)
- Developmental / Intellectual Disabilities
- Public Health(including pandemic response)
- Veterans Services(also through local VA outpatient clinic)
- Addiction and mental health services(crisis, addiction, adult and child/adolescent mental health services)
- Health-related
- Northeast Oregon Health Network (NEON), community health, insurance enrollment
- Housing/homelessness: NE Oregon Housing Authority, Union County Warming Station
- Domestic abuse/interpersonal violence (Shelter from the Storm)
- Disabilities services (New Day, RISE)
- Community Action Agency (CCNO, each county has one, Union’s is Community Connection)
- Services include food bank coordination, Meals-on-Wheels, elderly services, housing and utility assistance, transportation services
- Emily Safe Center(conducts examinations in child abuse allegations)
- Education
- Many services are located in public schools (for example), including psychiatric day treatment(through CHD)
- Head Start
- Special education
- Private
- Mental Health Organization (MHO, each Oregon County has at least one, Union’s is CHD)
Type of assistance
- Cash vs in-kind
- Entitlement vs block grants
Eligibility
- Means-tested vs insurance
- Different populations (affirmative action, age-based, veterans, mothers, children, etc.)
Programs
USDA and food:
Food stamps, commodity surplus buyback, school lunches, senior vouchers, WIC, Meals on Wheels, (more locally) community garden, Haven from Hunger, food bank
Housing/shelter
HUD, housing vouchers, homeless shelters, Habitat for Humanity, VA, FHA
Health care
Medicare, Medicaid, SCHIP, VA, hospice, elderly, home health, much has changed since the Affordable Care Act (e.g., expansion of Medicaid)
Insurance
Social security, SSI, workers’ compensation, unemployment
Cash, emergency assistance
- TANF, GA, disaster relief (GA, or general assistance, which is a state-level program and pretty much goneout of funding)
- EITC (working poor)
- Soup kitchens, homeless shelters
- Safe houses, shelters
Social services, safety/security
Parole/probation; prison programs; teen court/drug court; child protection, CASA, safehouses/shelters; mental health services,
Education
Head Start, Special education, day care/residential programs (e.g., Grande Ronde Child Center), many resources for children’s programs
Elderly
nursing homes, meals on wheels, assisted living,
Disabled
Special education/special needs programs; Group homes for the developmentally delayed population; SSI;
Therapy
Counseling, Substance abuse, parenting
Corporate welfare: Direct subsidies; Tax breaks
Non-economic
- Child and adult protective services (DHS, Safe Centers, CASA)
- Mental health services (therapy, substance abuse, counseling, CHD, RISE)
- Social work programs (e.g., in schools)
- People with disabilities (in La Grande—New Day, special ed)
Some trends: marriage, abstention, FBOs, welfare to work, cuts, devolution
- below the poverty line,
- victims of natural disasters,
- refugees seeking asylum from political persecution,
- migrant farm workers,
- disabled persons,
- the elderly,
- parolees from corrections,
- the unemployed,
- people without housing,
- children who’ve been removed from their homes,
- AIDS patients,
- victims of sexual assault / domestic violence
- veterans of war
Some statistics
- Total benefits from welfare programs (at federal level) by state, per person average
- Benefits as percent of national personal income (3% in 2011)
Sources:
- DiNitto, Diana. 2003. Social Welfare: Politics and Public Policy (5th edition). Boston: Allyn and Bacon